Quote:
Originally Posted by Eddien123
This is up there. I still prefer the E60. same weight with 107 more HP? Yes please  however, the styling of the e39 is just classical. Love seeing it on the road to this day. |
If you have not driven both, the power delivery is so different. The S85 engine in the E60 M5 is a future classic to be sure. However, it delivers a marginal increase in torque at a much higher RPM, rendering it more like the S54 in my M coupe. In daily driving, the extra horsepower and torque cannot be enjoyed. I drove both the SMG and 6-speed versions of the E60 M5 extensively. The SMG fits the engine better, but I still longed for a manual. The main reason I skipped the E60 was that when I was really enjoying it I was in danger of going to jail. Seriously - over 5000 RPM the engine and driving is nothing short of epic. I wanted everyone to get out of my way so I could enjoy the car. In daily driving, well, not so much. That plus the prospect of owning a V-10 out of warranty (I keep my cars for a long time) convinced me to wait.
Interestingly, the E39 was a break in the traditional M style of producing engines with modest low-down torque and high horsepower...until the current F8X. A BMW hotrod, at least at the time.
Anyway, I'm keeping the E39 (and Z4M coupe) and will be adding a modern M car soon - the M2 or M3 LCI...not sure yet.